A sub’s general liability policy expires in March. Nobody notices, because the certificate in the folder still looks fine. In May someone gets hurt on site, and that’s when the question comes up.
Lien waivers fail the same quiet way. The check went out, but the waiver that came back was on the wrong form, or never came back at all. This guide covers what to collect, what Texas requires, what Procore and Sage already do, and when an app or a custom build is worth it.
Why isn’t a certificate of insurance enough?
Because the certificate says so. The standard ACORD 25 form, like this sample from the City of Round Rock, states it is “issued as a matter of information only and confers no rights upon the certificate holder.” It also warns that a statement on the certificate “does not confer rights to the certificate holder in lieu of such endorsement(s).”
What’s on the certificate and what’s in the policy can differ. In an IRMI article, a risk consultant described reviewing hundreds of contractors over four years. The certificates showed full compliance, yet more than 90 percent had insurance that failed the contract’s requirements in a material way.
That’s one firm’s review, but the lesson holds. Collect the endorsements, not just the certificate.
What does it cost when this slips?
In Texas, a sub may have no workers’ comp at all. The Texas Department of Insurance says private employers can choose whether to carry it, and that coverage “is not required in most cases.” The same page explains how to check a company’s coverage through TDI’s TXCOMP lookup.
Public jobs are different. TxDOT notes that Texas requires contractors and subs on public building or construction projects to provide comp for each person employed on the project.
An uninsured sub can also show up on your own bill. At premium audit, insurers often charge you for subs without a certificate. BITCO, for example, says that without a current workers’ comp certificate it will “include the payroll of the subcontractor’s employees in the audit.”
Waivers carry a different cost. Under Texas Property Code Section 53.284, a waiver “is unenforceable unless it substantially complies” with the statutory form. A homemade form can leave a lien claim open after you’ve already paid.
What does Texas require for lien waivers?
Texas has four statutory forms: conditional and unconditional, each for progress payments and final payment. Section 53.281 says a waiver works only if it substantially follows one of those forms and is signed by the claimant or its agent. A conditional waiver only takes effect once there’s evidence of payment.
A common rhythm looks like this:
- With each pay app: a conditional progress waiver for the amount requested.
- After that payment clears: an unconditional progress waiver for it, often sent with the next pay app.
- At closeout: the final forms, conditional first, then unconditional once paid.
- From big suppliers and sub-tiers: the same waivers, if your contract requires them.
This isn’t legal advice. Have your construction attorney confirm your forms and your contract language.
What should I fix before buying anything?
Most COI problems are process problems. Fix these first.
- Put the requirements in the subcontract. List the coverages, limits and endorsements you need, such as additional insured for ongoing and completed operations, waiver of subrogation, and primary and non-contributory wording, plus whether you require workers’ comp. Texas limits what additional insured requirements can cover (Insurance Code Section 151.104), so set them with your broker and attorney.
- Use one inbox. Certificates and waivers go to one address, not to whichever PM the sub knows.
- Keep one list. For each sub: each policy’s expiry date, endorsements on file, and comp status. For each pay app: conditional in, unconditional for last payment in.
- Make one rule. No check goes out without a current certificate and the right waiver. AP holds it, and only your controller or president overrides.
- Ask the agent, not the sub. Thirty days before a policy expires, request the renewal certificate from the sub’s insurance agent.
What can Procore or Sage already do?
Procore. You can store each vendor’s insurance in the Directory. With “Send Expiration Notification” checked, Procore says it emails your insurance managers and the vendor’s contacts daily, starting about two weeks before expiry and continuing up to 60 days after.
Procore Pay. For waivers, Procore Pay uses what it calls “locked-until-paid” logic. Unconditional waivers release once payment reaches the sub’s bank. Ask your Procore rep whether it’s part of your plan.
Sage 300 CRE. It tracks insurance and lien waivers by vendor and job. According to training slides from RKL eSolutions, a Sage partner, it can show warnings at invoice entry and payment selection, and you can block payment of invoices.
All three track the dates and documents you enter. Someone still has to read each certificate and endorsement against your contract.
Which COI tracking apps are worth a look?
Dedicated trackers collect certificates and check them for you. A few that work with Procore:
- TrustLayer says it validates COIs against your criteria and alerts you before certificates expire.
- Jones collects documents through no-login links, audits them with risk specialists and OCR, and syncs compliance status to Procore nightly.
- Billy collects and verifies COIs, W-9s and licenses, and lists integrations with Procore and Sage 300.
If your problem is mainly certificates and you’re on Procore or Sage, one of these is likely your fastest fix.
When does a custom build make sense?
A custom build fits when documents arrive by email in every layout, and your records are split: certificates in Procore or Excel, payment holds in your accounting software, and nobody keeping the two in step. You want one check across insurance and waivers before each payment run.
Here, AI can read each certificate and endorsement, pull the dates, limits and named insureds, and compare them to your subcontract requirements. It can also read each waiver for the form, amount, through-date and signature.
Before every payment run, your PM and AP get a short list of who’s clear and who isn’t, with the source document one click away so anyone can check a limit the AI may have misread. AI never releases a payment; people decide.
How do I set it up, step by step?
- Write a one-page requirements sheet for each type of sub.
- Build the list from the last 12 months of certificates and waivers.
- Set up the shared inbox and tell every sub and agent to use it.
- Run a check before every payment run. Compare the run against the list and hold anything missing.
- Send renewal requests at 30 days, to the agent, with the requirements sheet attached.
- Follow the waiver rhythm above on every job.
- Spot-check endorsements on your largest subs each quarter.
What could this look like for a GC with 30 subs?
This is an illustration with made-up numbers, not a client story.
Say you’re a Houston GC with 30 active subs, each carrying three or four policies. That’s about 100 expiry dates a year. With monthly pay apps, you’d collect a conditional and an unconditional waiver from each sub, about 60 waivers a month.
At five minutes per document, the waivers alone take five hours a month. The hours aren’t the real cost, though. One check paid to a sub whose policy lapsed is.
Now add the list and the payment-run check. AP sees that one sub’s auto policy expired three days ago and holds that check. The agent sends the renewal, and the check goes out a day later.
When should I just buy an app?
Buy, don’t build, when:
- You run insurance and payments in one system, such as Procore with Procore Pay. Turn on expiration notifications, use its waiver tools, and add a COI tracker if you need certificates read.
- You have dozens of subs and want a vendor to chase agents for you.
- You have fewer than ten subs. A good list and the payment rule are enough.
Consider a custom build when documents come in every format, your project and accounting systems don’t share compliance dates, and you want one check before payment that matches how your AP actually works.
Want help setting up the check?
BlueHill is based in Spring, in north Houston, and works with clients over video and in person around Houston. The Document Matcher reads certificates, waivers and sub invoices, checks them against your records before each payment run, and shows your team only what doesn’t match. It’s built to work with Procore, your accounting software or Excel, and we confirm yours on the call. See how it fits construction companies, or book a free 30-minute call.